Lentil Stew and Other Important Things on Rice

Text for the Faculty Address to Incoming Students

August 24, 1997

Welcome to Rice. It is great that you are here!

It is especially wonderful to see you comfortably collapsed in the air conditioning after a hectic day of moving and greeting new people. In my book, you can consider this day an absolute, great success if you have managed to shove all of your boxes into your room, if the door actually closes behind them, and if you can still navigate your way to the bathroom and your bed! Unpacking and organizing is a thing for later…and that’s going to take planning.

In fact, planning is something I’d like to talk about this evening. What plan are you on? At Rice we have plans. We have meal plans, we have insurance plans, we have course plans. We have floor plans, parking plans and we have strategic plans. I could go on and on about the various plans that exist. Over the next week, and during the course of your time at Rice, you will have many opportunities to discuss and decide and debate among plans. As an active member of this community, you will have the opportunity to help construct plans, to change plans and even to terminate the plans that you think are no good. But this isn’t quite what I’m talking about tonight. Tonight I’m here to talk about the lentil stew. Yes, the lentil stew. But I’ll come back to that later.

When I ask the question "what plan are you on?" I am going back to an experience I had as an undergraduate which, in a very specific way, changed my approach to life. One of my professors asked the class to list five goals or projects in each of the following three categories: our 10-year plan, our 5-year plan, and our 24-hour plan. This request caught me off guard a bit. I had to really stop and think, especially to come up with five goals for each of the categories. After a considerable effort I was able to complete the list…and my eyes opened up a notch. I looked at what I’d written, I considered why some parts of it had been so tough to do, and I learned something major about myself.

So, again, welcome to Rice. I have your first assignment ready. Right now, as you sit, I’d like you to come up with just one response for each of the categories I mentioned. I’m going to stand quietly and let you think about this. (By the way, it has taken me more than 15 years as a professional "teacher" to learn that more learning takes place when I shut up than when I talk…and that’s what this is about.) So, give some thought to each: what is one thing you want to have achieved in 10 years? in 5-years? What is your goal for this time tomorrow night? Take a minute and see what you come up with. This is for you only, no one is going to collect it. And all you salty, wise old advisors…you do this, too. I was a senior when I did, and I wished I’d done it sooner.

(moment or two of silence)

All right. At this point I’m hoping you have some kind of response for each of the three categories. Realistically, one minute isn’t much time to do this exercise…unless of course you are running on auto-pilot…that you already have answers for these categories without having to think too much about it. If you are on auto-pilot… if this was exceptionally easy to answer… I ask that you spend a portion of your upcoming time at Rice reevaluating this list occasionally. Don’t stay on auto-pilot long; you will miss something. Maybe even the lentil stew.

In contrast, you may find that your goals slate right now is pretty clean. Perhaps you have just completed the big plan, the 10-year or 12-year plan… you’ve arrived at the university, you’ve begun to set up your own space, and (as of fifteen minutes ago) you’ve said your final good-byes to your family and packed your parents off. You’re sitting here breathing a huge sigh of relief, mixed perhaps with some apprehension, saying "Wow, I did it. I’m here, I’m on my own and I’m psyched to start this new phase of life." This is a natural point for setting goals and for redefining what is important. You have shifted into a brand new structure…there are no preconceptions here about who you are or about what your role will be in this community. These decisions are for you to make.

Now, I’m going to shift into absolute pure professor-mode for a moment. I’m lecturing…and it’s too easy to just coast through a lecture. So, listen. I’m getting ready to say something important. If this were a class, you would snap to attention, and hang on my every word. You might even take notes. This could be on the test.

Life offers us very few opportunities to completely shed one structure and to occupy a new one. We are humans, not arthropods. We don’t get to molt very often. This is a time to take stock of who you are and what you are about. This is a time when the definitions of others do not yet define you. Consider where the "authentic you" is. Shed any external skeletons that don’t really fit…things that you may have acquired, or to which you adapted, within a previous structure. If they don’t fit, shed them. And no one here will know that you did. Are you planning a triple major at Rice because you’ve always been a superachiever and folks expect that you will continue? Or do you really, truly, personally have a death-wish? If you really have a death wish, then do a triple major at Rice. If you are thinking about a triple major because it is part of the baggage you may have brought with you, then consider shedding that. Do you already know what your major is going to be because you chose it? Or because someone else expects it? Who defined who you were in high school? Were certain skills, behaviors, and attitudes expected of you then because of "who you were"? Those definitions of you don’t yet exist here. They will. Slowly but surely this structure will come to understand you and to interact with you and you will come to understand this structure and interact with it. As part of a natural process, the definition of who you are will become molded by, and enmeshed with, where you are. An organism that molts does so quickly, and there is a right time for the process. It happens when the old materials have been outgrown, or overused, or are no longer suitable. It is often a vulnerable time. It is a time, perhaps, of perceived or real risk. But vulnerable or not, there is no growing room until the unnecessary carapace is left behind. Shed what you need to shed, because you will wear this new structure for quite a while. This is the time. In life’s transitions, you’ve just entered the first big molt. And it’s worth thinking about.

Back to the exercise. That’s enough biology talk from a geologist. I’d like you to think through this exercise before Matriculation tomorrow night. Try to fill in five responses for each of the three categories. Leave blanks if you have to. You may find it rather difficult once you get past an obvious, selected few. But whether your slate is perfectly clean or absolutely filled with goals and objectives is not actually as important as the reading between the lines of what this list has to teach you.

To illustrate my point, I’ll go back to my responses to this exercise almost 20 years ago. It may give you some insight as to why I elected to make this a central theme of my talk tonight. I learned something about myself that I had never considered before, and I don’t know that I would have seen it had not an English professor made me do a what I viewed as a fluffy, touchy-feely kind of exercise. So, I’ll tell you a bit about it. But, first, let’s set some guidelines. Molting is, after all, kind of a personal thing. I’m not going to share my entire list with you. Some items I can easily discuss. I hate to admit it, but a few I can’t even remember. And several of my objectives were downright embarrassing… so there is no way I’m going to tell you. I hope for your own sake that there are some embarrassing ones on your list too…

I had no problem coming up with long term goals, although coming up with five long term goals was kind of hard. When it came to important things, I was a "one-goal" person. And the big one on the 10-year plan was to become a university professor. It is interesting that I set the goal of becoming a professor long before I had a clue what my major would be. I was going to be a professor of… something. I am, by the way, living proof that you can survive four semesters of holidays at home announcing a new major every time. Believe me, my parents just loved the conversations. We’d sit down around another lovely holiday meal and I would describe my latest lovely idea for a major. I ultimately settled on geology, and that was good because it filled in the "something" part of the "professor" part of the 10-year plan. Having set my 10-year plan, the 5-year plan was completely determined. Predetermined. I was headed to graduate school. That is what you did if you wanted to become a university professor. Now, my 24-hour plan was to get a huge pile of laundry done so that I wouldn’t have to go buy new clothes (that I couldn’t afford) and thereby run out of money needed to finish my undergraduate degree… so that I could graduate and go to graduate school and get a PhD… so that I could hunt for a job and become a university professor. And I’m not trying to be silly. What I realized that day was that my entire short term view was focused on the most direct route to the big plan. I was on a freight train, a freight train of my own making, headed as directly as possible toward that destination some 10 years down the track. And I was quite suspicious of any distraction or diversion that might deflect that linear course. And, by the way, I would never have tried something as suspicious looking as lentil stew.

Let’s continue reading for the lesson between the lines. My long term goals were solid, respectable, and attainable over the long term. I had a terrible time coming up with a list of short term goals because I really hadn’t produced any singular, independent short term goals. As my view focused closer and closer in time, looking ultimately at what I would do in the next twenty four hours, I saw my course as either being defined by someone else’s structure (going to grad school) or as being superficial (laundry). Now don’t get me wrong…these are perfectly acceptable goals to have. They are necessary. They are important. I just hadn’t produced them myself. My short term had to do with existing and getting on down the pike toward the big plan. I hadn’t set short term goals that stretched me at all. Keep in mind, other people were stretching me plenty hard over the short term. And you will definitely see that happen here at Rice. School was tough. I was proud to be doing well. I was busting my tail in the classroom and I was up to my neck in extracurricular activities. Intercollegiate athletics, intramurals, social things, clubs, committees. I was busy! I was having fun! But I was still missing out. Mentally, I was one step ahead of the present, on the path to somewhere else.

I kept reading between the lines and the situation got worse. I was following a sinister little unwritten agenda that said "don’t spend much time on anything that doesn’t contribute to the grand plan." Perhaps if my grand plan had been a bit more encompassing (like, for instance, save the world), I could have been happy with that. But my grand plan was pretty narrowly focused. I, therefore, was pretty narrowly focused and directly driven. The validity of the short term was for me defined on the basis of whether or not it fit constructively into the long term picture. Did it do me any good, or not, getting on down the pike? One of the greatest gifts I ever gave myself was to more fully open the doors to the present, and to reward myself for seeing and doing small things that had no obvious relevance to the big plan. At least not to my big plan. There are other big plans out there, and playing a small part in someone (or something) else’s grand plan is something we should all consider. Certainly, there is tremendous enrichment in life when you realize that things exist, not beyond the big plan, but in front of the big plan. That there is not one path to the 10-year goal, but that there are many paths. And that the diversions and distractions along these paths are what we call the living part.

So what do I want from you? Certainly not that you live my story. It is not so much in the detail of the goal as it is in reading between the lines. For every one of us who is a highly motivated, goal-oriented, narrow-minded path-walker there is another who is highly adept at collecting the moments…and for whom moments blend over time to produce a future seemingly unplanned.

So what do I want from you? I think I’ll be lucky to get two things out of you guys tonight…but I rarely leave a talk like this without extracting something. I want you to spend time with yourself this week (and that wont be easy…). I want you to focus on the shape of your 24-hour, your 5-year, and your 10-year plans. You might even hang onto the list for a while… comparisons over time can be instructive (and even downright funny). And while you’re doing this I want you to consider what external shells you’d like to shed. Quick, molt now…before, by your own actions, you sell anyone here on something about you that is outgrown, or overused, or that doesn’t suit you.

So what do I want from you? I like a quote by John Hoyt, President of the Humane Society, who said on Earth Day 1990: "Figure out what you care about and live a life that shows it." Dedicate your time at Rice to figuring out what you care about. Find creative ways to show it in both your daily life and your long-range plans. And always, always keep open to the distractions and the diversions that have so much more, and so much new, to teach us about what is really worth caring about.

Now, as for lentil stew. Here’s how I see it. When I was a college master, I set a personal goal…let’s see that would have been item #4 on my 5-year college master plan… and I obnoxiously pursued this goal. The goal was that every student in my college at least try the lentil stew before graduation. It was basically ugly, but it tasted very good and I knew in my heart that it was good for them. That’s how I feel about this exercise tonight. You may think this "molting thing," this "goals thing," is basically ugly, but it is really quite good, and I know in my heart that it is good for you. So, here’s the link. When you see lentil stew being served in the college, that’s your signal from me to stop and ponder what plan you are on. Evaluate your goals and, most importantly, read between the lines. Where is the list easy to fill out? Where is it tough to fill out? Where is it superficial? Where is it filled in by somebody else? And on at least one of those occasions, you have to actually try the lentil stew. For my part in this, I’ll ask CK not to serve this lentil stuff more than once a week (leftovers don’t count). That way you won’t have to think too often. And I’ll keep an eye on my e-mail. You let me know when you’ve tried the lentil stew, and I’ll be sure your lentil stew requirement is cleared for graduation. Just think, you could have one of your graduation requirements completed before Thanksgiving…if you’re brave enough.

I’ve said what I really came to say this evening. And I’ve taken less time than I was allotted. I’m going to give that time to you. Perhaps you’ll use it to think more about what plan you are on. Perhaps you’ll start to compare the external you with the internal you. Does everything still fit? I know I wouldn’t mind seeing a carapace or two hanging from the trees around here.

"Figure out what you care about and live a life that shows it."

Does anybody know if they are serving lentil stew for dinner tonight?